In the week before Black Friday, “up to 70% off” was all over Instagram, including from some well-known fashion brands. If a big, established brand discounts that hard, it is natural to ask whether you should too: take a loss on Black Friday and win customers who pay full price later.
Sometimes that works. Often it does not, and the evidence mostly points one way: customers won with a deep discount tend to be worth less, and most do not come back. A short loss for a long gain is a bet, not a rule. If you cannot say what the loss is buying, do not discount that deep.
Why can a big brand do it when you may not?
An established brand has things a newcomer does not: years of brand building, customers who already know it, and a business big enough to absorb an expensive sale. It may also have stock to clear, which is one of the better reasons for a deep discount, as we cover below. “Up to” usually means only some lines go that low, too. We do not know why any particular brand chooses the discount it does, and we will not guess. What we can say is that a large, long-established business is in a very different position from a newcomer.
Do customers won on a discount come back?
Less often than you would hope. A study published in the Journal of Marketing Research in 2006 looked at customers of a newspaper and an online grocer. The deeper the discount that first brought customers in, the less often they bought again. In one example from the study, customers who came in on a 35% discount were worth about half as much over time as those who came in without one. Those are not fashion or beauty businesses, but the pattern is a warning.
Retail figures point the same way, though they come from software companies that sell to retailers, so treat them with care. Ometria, a customer data company, reports that only 4% of the new customers its retail clients won on Black Friday 2024 bought again within 12 months, and that they were six times less likely to return than typical new customers. Ometria has not published its sample or method. Of the few who did buy again, it says three quarters did so on the next Black Friday. And coming back is not the same as coming back at full price.
There is a second cost that is easy to miss. Some of the people who buy in your sale would have bought anyway, at full price. Others are existing customers buying in November what they would have bought in December. The discount on those orders is margin given away, not new business.
Are Black Friday prices really the best of the year?
Often not. Which? tracked 175 home, tech and health appliances at eight retailers and found that 83% were the same price or cheaper at least once in the six months either side of the 2024 Black Friday sale period. Its retail editor called Black Friday “a false economy” for most shoppers. That research covers appliances, not fashion or beauty.
There is also a longer-term risk. Pricing research has long found that people judge a price against what they have paid or seen before, which researchers call a reference price. A brand that is 70% off every November is teaching its customers what it is “really” worth. That last step is our reading of the research, not something the research tests directly.
Are other small businesses still doing Black Friday?
Many are not. In a 2025 survey by Bira, the British Independent Retailers Association, 77% of the small businesses it asked said they were rejecting Black Friday, up from 69% the year before. Bira does not give the number surveyed. Bira’s Andrew Goodacre put it plainly: “Black Friday simply doesn’t work for independent retailers.”
Shoppers may also have less to spend this year. A survey by Omnisend, a marketing software company, forecasts UK spending of £9.9bn from Black Friday to Cyber Monday 2026, against its own estimate of £14.5bn for 2025. About a quarter of people say they will buy nothing, slightly fewer than last year, but those who do buy expect to spend less. Surveys of Black Friday spending vary widely, so treat the size with caution. Omnisend’s own advice was that “the worst response to a smaller spending budget is a bigger blanket discount”.
Some brands opt out of the day itself. The Ordinary is again closing its website and its shops on Black Friday, 27 November 2026, as it has for several years, though it still runs other offers during November. In the US, the outdoor retailer REI closed its doors on Black Friday from 2015. That year its sales rose 9.3% and its online sales 23%, but its profits fell, partly because of a large payout to its members. REI is a big co-operative, not a small brand, so it shows that opting out can be done rather than that it pays.
When is a Black Friday loss worth taking?
There are a few good reasons to discount deeply:
- Clearing stock you would otherwise write off or sell for less later.
- Proof from your own data that last year’s Black Friday new customers came back and bought at full price.
- Something people reorder, such as a consumable or a subscription, when you know how often they do.
- Building your email list, when you know what a subscriber is worth to you over a year.
Outside those, a deep discount is mostly a cost.
What should you check before you decide?
- Your margin at the sale price, product by product, after postage, payment fees, returns and the advertising cost of each order.
- What last year’s Black Friday new customers did next. How many bought again within 12 months, and at what share of full price? Compare them with new customers from other months, not with your existing customers.
- Your stock. How many weeks of it you hold, how old it is, and what it would fetch otherwise.
- What a new customer costs you, against what they bring in over 12 months, not just on the first order.
- A point at which you stop, set before the sale starts. For example: stop discounting a line if fewer than a set number have sold by day three.
If you have no figures on last year’s customers, run a small, capped test and read the result before going bigger.
What does 70% off do to a single order?
Here is a made-up example to show the maths. Take a product that sells for £60. It costs you £18 to make and get to your warehouse, £4 to post, and card fees of about 2%. Say each order also costs you £8 in advertising. To keep it simple, the example leaves out VAT and returns.
- At full price (£60): about £29 left on each order.
- At 20% off (£48): about £17 left.
- At 70% off (£18): a loss of about £12 on every order, before any returns.
To win that £12 back, the customer has to come back and buy again. A full-price repeat order with no advertising cost leaves about £37. So roughly one in three of those Black Friday customers would need to return and buy at full price just to cover the loss on their first order. If the real figure is nearer the 4% Ometria reports, the sale loses money on almost every new customer it brings in.
What can a small brand do instead?
- A free gift with orders over a set amount. Your cost is the gift, not a cut across every order.
- Early access for your email list. It rewards the people most likely to come back, and gives others a reason to sign up.
- A bundle at a better price than buying the items separately.
- A modest offer, kept honest. A real “was” price and no countdown clock that resets itself.
- Skipping it on purpose, and telling your customers why.
The short version
A deep Black Friday discount works best as a way to clear stock, or for a brand that already knows its sale customers come back at full price. For most small brands it is a cost, not an investment: the evidence we have suggests the customers it brings in are worth less and often do not return, and some of the discount goes to people who would have paid full price anyway. Work out your margin at the sale price, look at what last year’s Black Friday customers did next, and decide what the loss is buying before you set the price. If you cannot answer that, a gift, early access or a bundle will usually do more for you.
FAQ
Is Black Friday worth it for a small business?
It can be, if you use it to clear stock or you have your own figures showing that Black Friday customers come back. In a 2025 Bira survey, 77% of the small businesses it asked said they were not taking part.
Do Black Friday customers come back?
Fewer than you might hope. Ometria, a customer data company, reports that only 4% of its clients’ Black Friday 2024 new customers bought again within a year. Research on a newspaper and an online grocer found customers won on deeper discounts were worth less over time.
How much should a small brand discount on Black Friday?
There is no right number. Work from your margin after postage, fees, returns and advertising, and set the discount so each order still covers its costs unless you have a clear reason to take a loss.
What can you do instead of a discount?
A free gift with orders over a set amount, early access for your email list, a bundle, or a small honest offer. Some brands, such as The Ordinary, close for the day instead.
Is it a good idea to skip Black Friday?
It can be, as long as you tell your customers and give them a reason to come back. It is a choice many independents now make.
Sources: Lewis, Customer Acquisition Promotions and Customer Asset Value, Journal of Marketing Research (2006); Ometria, Black Friday 2025 data (December 2025); Which?, Don’t believe the hype: most Black Friday deals the same price or cheaper at other times of the year (November 2025); Kalyanaram and Winer, Empirical Generalizations from Reference Price Research, Marketing Science (1995); Bira, Independent retailers reject Black Friday (November 2025); Retail Gazette, Black Friday discount war risks backfiring as UK shoppers cut budgets by a third (November 2026); Hypebae, The Ordinary is yet again closing its doors for Black Friday (November 2026); Retail Dive, REI’s record membership growth boosts online, in-store sales (March 2016).